Before I go any further with this post, I want to make one thing clear – I am not bashing homeless people. Not even in the slightest bit. I am one of the few who ALWAYS gives a dollar or two when I pass by a homeless person – I have nothing against them.
Back to the question; why are the homeless, homeless? Living in the Bay Area, I visit San Francisco quite often. San Francisco is a pretty fun place – lot’s to do there. But every time I go there, I come back asking myself the same question over and over. Why are the homeless, homeless? San Francisco has one of the highest homeless populations, and it is kind of ironic, seeing as it is such a wealthy area. There a few specific streets in San Francisco that are particularly quite bad. I can’t exactly remember the names now, but I’ll try to find out. The majority of homeless people are quite nice people – they usually ask you for money, and if you don’t want to give them any, they leave you alone. That’s has been how the majority of experiences have been for me.
Now, even though a good number of my experiences with homeless people have been good, I’ve had some bad ones too. Before I actually moved to California, I came on a 2 week vacation here with my father and sister (summer of 2007). My family seems to not be able to look at a homeless person without giving them some money – so yes, we usually do. Now, this one case was kind of funny, but scary for my sister. We were in San Francisco at burger shop, sometime around noon. Anyways, a homeless man approached us, and said his name was “Odis” – neat name, huh? As my sister pulled out the cash from her pocket – a whole bunch of one dollar bills, and a five dollar bill. As she tried to separate the money (a few one dollar bills) from the bunch to give Odis, he did something that shocked me. He yanked it all out of her hand and ran. Being a girl and quite delicate, she got quite scared and upset. Me and my dad thought it was pretty funny, and didn’t bother chasing Odis for $10.
Recently, I was in San Francisco, and came across a weird encounter. I ended up on the wrong street – yes, I mean the wrong street. I really regret going there, as it was quite dangerous. Everyone looked as if they wanted to kill me. One man even yelled at me and said “It’s because of you my people are out here on the streets!”, which really got me thinking for the rest of the day. Is it because of people like me (regular people) that these homeless people are homeless? I was offended in a way, because I never did anything wrong to a homeless person. I’m sure others will have a different opinion on this, but quite frankly, I feel that homeless people are homeless simply because they chose that path. I am not saying that is the case with all homeless people, just the majority. I will explain further below.
Many of these homeless individuals started there because of an addiction to a drug, or drugs. Although addiction is something that is close to impossible to control, they made that first chose to start. They could have chose the other path, and the chances of them ending up on the streets would have been a lot less likely. The part that confuses me the most is that many of these homeless people are good people – so why do they not make an attempt to get off of the streets? I’m sure some will say that is it easier said then done – and to those, I completely agree. But what would you do if you were homeless? Would you not make an attempt to get off of the streets? Personally, I would.
There is so much opportunity out there in the world, and I see no reason as for why these people are homeless. Once again, maybe I need to experience it first hand to realize their situation. But quite frankly, I do not understand how they landed there in the first place, in such a country (I’m talking about the USA specifically). Many children grow up in families that are poor, abusive, and so on, but they still end up living an average, if not above average life. You are the one who steers your own life, and if you want, you can ensure that you do not land on the streets. I feel that a homeless person telling me it is my fault he is on the streets is a bit unfair. I could change my life onto the wrong path – drugs, drop out of school, and so on. But the thing is, I choose not to, and these homeless individuals could have done the same.
So why do I feel that the majority of homeless people are homeless? Personal choice. Just my opinion though. I’m sure there is a wide variety of perspectives on this matter. Just please remember, I am not bashing homeless people. I have a lot of sympathy for them. I try to help out whenever I can, by giving them some money – but I can only do so much.
Why do you think that homeless people are homeless?

{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }
You can find huge amount of homeless people in India. What you’re seeing there in San Francisco is just a percentage or below 5% of what you can see in India.
Good question. You could argue for days and days on this issue without having an answer. There was a guy (www.nevblog.com) down in Texas who went out on the streets to experience whats it like to be homeless.
There was also a post on reddit a while back about the same issue, read some of the comments if you have time, some of the people in comments actually were homeless. (http://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/8yvpg/i_recently_asked_my_friends_little_girl_what_she/)
Why am i homeless lets see. for most it might be vice like drinking , drugs and ect. Lets not ask that question how is not a important the fact is that it happens. I think what is more important is what keeps people homeless.
As for me I don’t do any drugs have any vices other then managing my money poorly a touch of ADHD. But there was nothing more shameful then becoming homeless. So i ran from my home state. then i lost my id and anything of any value. slowing down and trying to find programs can be harder then you might think there are many homeless people not even look to become unhomeless.
Sometime if i was addicted to something it would be easier. I would have a better excuse but i don’t and it’s only purity much shame that keeps me trapped. Starting over in another state take a while and i would become ashamed and move on or not get the kind of help i need.
which at the time was glasses. i needed glasses to work and i couldn’t get glasses with out work. i could never find right place or time. losing and id and everything else made it imposable to qualify for help.
i went back to my home state and got glasses. and now I’m infested with bed bugs and might so i can stay anywhere but out side till i figure out how to cure it …. fuck it sucks.
Working on it is very hard and shameful and maybe i should be shamed. I’m going to move on from my home state soon and away from my family so that i can pretend to them that everything is OK and my friends will hear nothing about it.(god my legs still ich)
lets hope there is help for me outside my home state so i can maintain some dignity while trying to get a home together. i hate to beg especially when there are people i know there. I know it will be harder if not imposable but it’s worth the little dignity that I might have left. I have already ask everyone I know for help. Now I don’t want them to see me beg for help from complete strangers.
The funny thing is I have qualifications for a great job but no means to get the job. That also works agents me. So yes after I get what I can form my home state, I will leave and still be homeless till I can find help. If that help comes when that help comes at least my loved ones will not know what I’m up to. Because there is no way I’m proud of it.
P.S. The lack of sleep dose not help you never know whats going to happen in the middle of the night and you don’t have a home
The Transient,
I am extremely happy you dropped by. Nothing is better then hearing it from someone who has experienced it. I hope I didn’t seem rude or anything of that sort in the post. Like I said, I have a good heart and always try to help the homeless when I can.
I’m shocked as for your story. You’ve put me in a situation where I’m speechless. Your story seems very rough, and you seem like a VERY courageous individual. With an attitude like yours, you can recover and get off the streets for good.
If you ever want to talk, don’t be afraid to email me.
Yeah, you’re right. I should have mentioned that. I was just using this as an example. Obviously, there are parts of the world which have a much higher percentage of homeless individuals.
I agree Jason. It is a controversial question. Thanks for posting the link to Nev’s blog BTW — I read that post a while ago, but I’m sure some of my readers have not seen it. Definitely a cool experiment he did.
I did not realize until later if i should have posted other links in comments.
Yeah it is a good post, and he had it detailed pretty good.
No worries Jason — the link you posted was relevant, so it’s fine.